1872 Cafe Menu

Located in Rochester, NY, 1872 Cafe offers a diverse menu featuring pizza, coffee, and tea in a classy yet casual setting. The cafe provides a wide range of amenities such as delivery, takeout, vegan options, and women-owned ownership.

Customers rave about the homey atmosphere, generous portions, and mouthwatering dishes like the shrimp and grits, Suzy B breakfast pizza, and Freddie D Veggie breakfast sandwich. The 1872 veggie wrap is a popular choice, with tofu, hummus, and fresh vegetables.

With friendly staff, delicious food, and an inspiring space filled with books and board games, 1872 Cafe is a must-visit spot for breakfast, lunch, or working. The cafe also offers outdoor seating, private dining, and a parking lot for added convenience. Experience the taste of history and story-worthy food at 1872 Cafe.

Breakfast Menu

Egg Souffle

real Eggs = Scrambled in their own skillet pan with cheddar cheese and includes two add-ins.

$9.75

Bagel

Toasted or Untoasted with butter

$3.50

Belgian Waffle

Comes dressed with powdered sugar and cinnamon sprinkles. Butter and syrup are listed seperately for environmental needs.

$10.25

Classic Breakfast Sandwich

Choice of : Turkey Bacon, Sausage, or Ham; Egg, Cheddar, and Breakfast Sauce on your choice of bread.

$7.10

Freddie D Veggie

skillet baked Eggs w/ Cheddar, Onion, Spinach, Tomato topped w/ Breakfast Sauce on your choice of bread.

$6.95

Suzy B Steak

Our signature breakfast sandwich of egg, onions, roasted red peppers, steak, mozzarella, and Breakfast sauce on your choice of bread.

$7.25

Slices Of Toast

Two slices of toast, served with a selection of spreads such as butter, peanut butter, or jam.

$1.79

Croissant

Buttery croissant with options for extra toasted, light toast, not toasted, or just toasted.

$1.99

Fish N Grits

oz lightly seasoned White fish (no bones about it) steamed/baked with olive oil, basil, fresh wilted spinach, onion & tomato, over our famous & very popular grits. ( Fridays after am or hour advanced notice any other day) because we do not pre cook anything...

$13.50

Shrimp N Grits Large

Sautéed shrimp served over a generous portion of creamy grits, typically includes a blend of cheeses.

$12.00

Grits W/Italian Sausage

Creamy grits served with Italian sausage. Options include small or large size.

$8.25

Shrimp N Grit's Small

Tender shrimp atop creamy grits, garnished with sautéed bell peppers and a sprinkle of herbs.

$9.15

Grits N Cheddar Large

Creamy grits combined with melted cheddar cheese, served in a generous portion.

$6.15

Grits W/Cheddar Small

Creamy grits topped with melted cheddar cheese and garnished with a sprinkle of herbs.

$4.50

Grits

Coffee

Americano

Hot euro style espresso with hot water.

$2.45

Drip Coffee

Drip coffee served hot or cold.

$2.75

Cafe Au Lait

Hot brewed coffee with a touch of steamed milk on top (so your coffee doesn't get cold too fast) add a flavor shot for the personal touch.

$2.60

Cappuccino

Fresh espresso with steamed milk and foam on top. add a flavor shot to make it personal.

$3.85

Coffee Refill

A coffee refill offers a freshly brewed cup from our selection, typically featuring a blend with notes of chocolate and caramel.

$0.90

Espresso

Espresso, with options for double shot or single shot.

$1.75

Flavor Of The Day

Pistachio flavor (mwf) an the rest of the week can be pecan, jtalian macaroon or jamaican. keep it fun and tasty.

$2.25

Hot Cocoa Steamer

Warm, rich chocolate with a choice of % milk, almond, oat, or whole milk. Available in oz, oz, oz, oz sizes.

$2.95

House Medium Roast

A carefully selected blend, typically featuring a balance of flavors from various regions, roasted to achieve a medium body and smooth finish.

$2.50

Latte

Fresh espresso with steamed milk and a bit of foam on top. add a flavor shot to make it your own.

$3.95

Macchiato

Steamed milk with fresh espresso on top. add a flavor to make it your own.

$3.95

Mocha

$4.30

Undertow Shot

Choice of flavor, half n half , and fresh espresso double shot for fresh pick me up. served in a small cup as it is a "shooter style" pick me up.

$2.50

Elephant

Elephant Chai Tea: Available in oz, oz, oz. Choice of hot or cold. Milk options include %, almond, oat, or whole.

$4.25

Flamingo

Chai tea blend, available in oz, oz, oz. Choose between cold or hot. Milk options include %, almond, oat, or whole milk.

$4.25

Orca Chai

Bold blend available in oz, oz, oz. Choice of hot or cold. Milk options include %, almond, oat, or whole.

$4.25

Tiger

Tiger Chai Tea: Available in oz, oz, oz. Choice of cold or hot. Milk options include %, almond, oat, whole.

$4.25

Tortoise

Tortoise chai tea, available in oz, oz, and oz sizes. Option for served cold or hot. Milk choices include %, almond, oat, or whole milk.

$4.25

Vegan Power

Vegan Power Chai Tea: Choice of cold or hot, available in oz, oz, oz. Milk options include %, almond, oat, whole.

$4.45

David Rio Chai

Frappes & Smoothies

Oreo

Oreo smoothie, available in oz, oz, oz with size surcharge options.

$5.15

PB Mocha

Peanut butter blended with rich mocha, available in oz, oz, oz.

$5.15

Plain Frappe

Liquid ice-cream, ice, and coffee blended and topped with whipped cream.

$3.95

Protein Shake

Powder plant protein blended with you milk choice and ice to be thick. add - on items available to make it your own

$4.45

Smoothies

Strawberry, mango, strawberry banana, or mixed berry.

$3.95

Chamomile

Chamomile tea, available in oz, oz, oz sizes.

$2.95

Earl Grey

Earl Grey tea available in oz, oz, oz sizes.

$2.95

English Breakfast

Traditional English Breakfast tea. Size options: oz, oz, oz.

$2.95

Green Tea

Green tea, available in oz, oz, or oz sizes.

$2.95

Herbal Hibiscus Berry

Hibiscus Berry Herbal Tea: Available in oz, oz, oz.

$2.99

Teas

Fries & Tots

Baked Fries

Oven-baked potato fries, seasoned with a blend of herbs and spices for a lighter alternative.

$3.75

Baked Tots

Golden, crispy tater tots with a tender, fluffy interior.

$4.25

Chili Fries W/Cheese

Crispy fries topped with savory chili and melted cheese, garnished with beans.

$8.00

Baked Fries Large

Oven-baked large fries, seasoned with a blend of herbs and spices for a crispy finish.

$5.95

Tot Plate With Eggs And Cheddar

Tater tots topped with two eggs and melted cheddar cheese.

$8.75

Cheese Pizza

Options include " medium, " large thin crust, or half sheet. Sauce choices: bleu cheese, garlic & olive oil, olive oil, ranch, red sauce.

$12.99

" Gluten Free / Vegan Pizza

Gluten-free crust topped with optional bleu cheese, garlic & olive oil, ranch, or red sauce.

$13.79

Vegan Pizza " Gluten Free & Vegan Crust

Our vegan crust w/ vegan sauce and vegan cheese. -". (whole only)

$13.79

Cheese Slice

Cheese pizza slice, choice of bleu cheese, ranch, or Italian dressing.

$3.95

Speciality Slice

Specialty slice pizza with choice of bleu cheese, ranch, or Italian dressing.

$4.15

Cheese Slice Combo

Cheese pizza with choice of bleu cheese, ranch, or Italian dressing. Combo includes bottle or can soda and options of banana, brownie, chips, or donut.

$6.95

Specialty Slice Combo

Choice of bleu cheese, ranch, or Italian dressing. Accompanied by a selection of either a bottle or can of soda. Side options include banana, brownie, chips, or donut.

$7.50

Meat Lovers Breakfast

Egg Base, Turkey Bacon, Sausage, Mozzarella & Cheddar

$16.55

Suzy B Steak Breakfast

Egg Base, Steak, Roasted Red Peppers, Onion and Mozzarella with breakfast sauce drizzle.

$16.95

Veggie Breakfast

Egg Base, Spinach, Mushroom, Banana Peppers, Mozzarella & Cheddar

$16.25

Popeye's Spinach Breakfast

Egg Base, Spinach, Mushroom, Banana Peppers, Mozzarella & Cheddar

$15.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Ranch Base, Chicken, Turkey Bacon, Mozzarella

$17.25

Buffalo Chicken

Bleu Cheese Base, Chicken, Buffalo Sauce & Mozzarella

$17.25

Main St. Meat Lovers Pizza

Ham, pepperoni, Roasted Red Peppers & Mozzarella

$15.99

Margherita

Red Sauce, Sliced Tomato, Spinach, Mozzarella and Basil

$16.75

Pizza

Sandwiches

Burger

Seasoned All-Beef /lb Burger, Ciabatta Roll, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion and Mayo.

$9.99

Burger Plate

All-Beef /lb Burger, Oven-Baked Fries, Mac Salad, and topped with Bean Chili.

$11.49

Cheese Panini

Choice of bread and cheese. Customize with your own toppings!

$6.75

Chicken On Ciabatta

Sliced Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo on a Ciabatta Roll.

$6.50

Landmark Buffalo Chicken

Breast Chicken, Buffalo Sauce, Bleu Cheese, Spinach, Tomato and Banana Peppers, Served on a spinach wrap.

$9.25

Meatball Cup

All-Beef Meatballs in our own blend of tomato sauce.

$6.75

The "Freddie-Sue" Tuna

Seasoned Albacore Tuna, Mayo with Choice of Bread.

$8.25

The Downtown Steak Sub

Sub roll, Shaved Steak, Onions, Roasted Red Peppers, Mozz Cheese, Boss sauce.

$8.95

The Main Street Turkey Sub "

Deli Turkey , served on a Sub Roll. Customize with your own toppings and cheese.

$8.25

The Main Street Turkey Sub"

Deli Turkey , served on a Sub Roll. Customize with your own toppings and cheese.

$13.75

Burger Small Fry Water Combo

Burger accompanied by a small serving of fries and a water, typically includes a beef patty on a bun with classic toppings.

$12.99

Panini Special

Panini with choice of American, Cheddar, Mozzarella, Provolone, Swiss, Vegan Cheese, or no cheese.

$12.25

Salad W/Chicken

Romaine Lettuce, Red Cabbage, Carrots, Cucumbers and Tomatoes, Cheddar, Croutons.

$10.25

Chili oz

Homemade Vegan Chili

$5.15

Clam Chowder oz

House-made New England Style Clam Chowder. Roasted Carrots, Potatoes, Onions, and Celery. Lots of clams, in a thick creamy soup, Gluten Free!

$5.95

Garden Salad Large

Romaine Lettuce, Red Cabbage, Carrots, Cucumbers and Tomatoes

$7.95

Gumbo oz

House-made Chicken and Shrimp Gumbo

$5.95

Small Mac And Cheese

Cheddar, Mozzarella, and Romano Cheeses in a creamy sauce over elbow mac.

$6.25

Soup And Salad Combo

A pairing of a cup of our daily soup with a fresh garden salad, typically including mixed greens and a variety of vegetables.

$10.33

Taco Salad

/ lb Ground Seasoned % Beef, Onions, Black Beans, Cheddar, Tomatoes & Fritos. Tangy Dressing Included

$12.99

Tomato Basil Soup oz

House-made Tomato Basil Soup with Crackers or House Croutons.

$5.15

Chicken & Rice oz

Chicken and rice in a savory broth, typically includes vegetables and herbs.

$5.65

French Onion oz

Caramelized onions simmered in a rich beef broth, traditionally served with a topping of toasted baguette and melted gruyere cheese.

$8.25

Garden Salad Small

Romaine Lettuce, Red Cabbage, Carrots, Cucumbers and Tomatoes

$4.50

Side Dressing\Sauces

A selection of house-made dressings and sauces, typically accompanying salads or sides to enhance flavors.

$0.65

Tomato Soup oz

A smooth blend of pureed tomatoes and a careful selection of herbs, creating a classic soup experience.

$4.95

Tomato Basil oz

House-made Tomato Basil Soup with Crackers or House Croutons.

$8.15

Large Mac And Cheese

Macaroni pasta enveloped in a creamy, rich cheese sauce, often garnished with breadcrumbs for a satisfying crunch.

$9.25

Soups, Salads, Sides

Specialty

Betty White

A flavorful latte with vanilla flavored milk and caramel sauce on top. hot or cold is a sweet tribute to the sweet actress / comedian.

$4.85

Eleanor

Specialty coffee, available in oz, oz, oz. Choose hot or cold. Milk options: %, almond, oat, whole.

$5.15

Ella Fitzgerald

Latte flavored with spicy ginger and sweet praline topped with a sprinkle of cinnamon.

$4.55

Matcha

Choose size (oz, oz, oz) and temperature (cold, hot). Select milk: %, almond, oat, or whole.

$5.15

Maya Rudolph

Mocha latte with sweet hazelnut topped with whipped cream.

$4.85

"Not Gulty" Chili Fries

French fries topped with a hearty vegan chili, made with a blend of beans, tomatoes, and spices, finished with vegan cheese.

$8.15

Veggie Wrap

Spinach wrap filled with a blend of fresh, seasonal vegetables.

$8.95

Vegan Plate

A medley of seasonal vegetables, thoughtfully prepared to highlight their natural flavors, served on a base that complements their textures and tastes.

$12.20

Bagel W/Vegan Butter

Bagel served with vegan butter. Choices include blueberry, everything, gluten-free, plain. Toasting options range from extra to not toasted.

$2.99

Good Day Rosa

Selection of breads including grain, blueberry and everything bagel, ciabatta, croissant, Texas toast, various gluten-free options, or spinach wrap.

$6.25

Grandma's Vegan "Toona" Sandwich

Vegan "Tonna" sandwich with an array of bread options including grain, ciabatta, various bagels, and gluten-free choices. Opt for extra patty or without bread.

$6.95

Hearty -Bean Chili

A hearty mix of three types of beans, this chili combines tomatoes, onions, and a blend of spices, embodying the essence of traditional chili without animal products.

$4.95

Vegan French Onion

A savory blend of caramelized onions and a rich, hearty broth, typically accompanied by a slice of toasted bread topped with melted vegan cheese.

$4.95

Vegan Veggie Burger

Vegan veggie burger with options for bread including grain, various bagels, ciabatta, croissant, texas toast, gluten-free options, Italian sub roll, or spinach wrap.

$8.95

Vegan Mac Salad

Macaroni pasta mixed with a variety of vegetables and a creamy, dairy-free dressing.

$2.49

Vegan Menu

Wings

Boneless Wings

Offers a choice of flavors including buffalo hot, various "Sal's Birdland" options, sweet boss sauce, and plain, with sauce options.

$14.95

Bone -In Wings

bone-in chicken wings served with a choice of flavors including buffalo hot, plain options, Sal's Birdland varieties, Jamaican, and sweet boss sauce.

$16.95

Wings

wings served with a choice of flavors: Buffalo hot, unsauced, sauce on the side, Sal's Birdland options (BBQ, sassy hot, sassy mild), Jamaican, and sweet boss sauce.

$27.95

Apple Fritter\ Bear Claw\Cherry Turn

Deep-fried dough mixed with apple pieces, typically dusted with cinnamon and sugar. Bear claw: Pastry dough filled with almond paste, shaped like a bear's paw, often topped with sliced almonds and powdered sugar. Cherry turn: Sweet pastry filled with cherry compote, folded into a turnover shape.

$2.99

Brownies

Perfect for the sweet tooth in you

$1.79

Regular Pack Cookies

Fresh baked cookies, assorted flavors.

$2.85

Glazed Donut

Classic glazed donut coated in our famous glaze.

$1.79

Large Muffins

Baked daily, these generously sized muffins come in a variety of flavors such as blueberry, chocolate chip, and banana nut.

$3.50

Specialty Donut

A specialty donut often features unique and innovative flavors or fillings, typically including a blend of classic and creative ingredients to offer a distinct taste experience.

$1.99

Carrot Cake

Classic moist cake made with fresh carrots, rich cream cheese frosting, and a hint of spice.

$3.59

Cheesecake

Smooth and rich, our Creamy Cheesecake is the perfect way to satisfy your sweet tooth.

$3.69

Pastries

Retail

Bulk Coffee / Lb

Half-pound of drip coffee beans, offering a balanced and smooth taste suitable for everyday enjoyment.

$7.99

Banana

A ripe, elongated yellow fruit known for its sweetness and soft texture, often eaten as a snack or used in various dishes for its flavor.

$1.00

Snack Nuts

A selection of nuts, typically including a variety of both sweet and savory flavors, catering to diverse palates.

$1.50

Coffee Mug

A durable coffee mug, often featuring a unique design or logo, suitable for your daily coffee rituals.

$9.99

Fruit Cup

$3.35

Gummies

A variety of chewy, fruit-flavored candies, often in fun shapes or coated with sugar for an extra sweet touch.

$1.99

Healthy Chips

Healthy chips typically include a blend of nutrient-dense ingredients, baked to achieve a satisfying crunch.

$1.69

Oatmeal

Hearty, warm cereal made from oats

$1.95

Parfait

Greek yogurt layered with our signature granola and a medley of fresh strawberries and blueberries.

$3.49

Sargento Crackers

Sargento crackers are typically savory, incorporating a blend of cheeses for a rich taste in each bite.

$1.99

T Shirts

Soft, wearable cotton with a unique coffee-themed design, reflecting the spirit of coffee culture.

$12.50

Fit Crunch Bar

A fit crunch bar typically includes a blend of proteins, often whey, encased in chocolate with layers of crunchy texture and a hint of sweetness.

$1.99

Ice Water Cup

Cup filled with ice water.

$0.30

Pre-Made Wrap/Sandwich From Cooler

A pre-made wrap or sandwich, typically filled with a combination of meats, cheeses, fresh vegetables, and condiments, all encased in a soft tortilla or fresh bread.

$6.99

V Scones

A vegan scone, incorporating a variety of ingredients to achieve a tender and satisfying pastry experience.

$4.95

Vegan Cookies

A pack of three vegan cookies, typically crafted with a variety of plant-based ingredients to cater to diverse tastes.

$7.25

Vegan / G Free Bar

A blend of gluten-free and vegan ingredients come together to create a bar that typically includes a variety of nuts, seeds, and sweeteners for a satisfying treat.

$2.99

Vegan Pastries

Retail Drinks

Sunny D Small

Tangy citrus blend, a classic favorite.

$1.25

Liter Soda

A carbonated beverage available in various flavors to cater to diverse tastes.

$2.89

Liter Water

liter of purified drinking water, offering hydration in a convenient size.

$2.50

Smart Water

Every drop tastes pure and will leave you feeling refreshed.

$2.89

Dasani Water Oz

Enhanced with a proprietary blend of minerals to give it the clean, fresh taste you want from water.

$1.99

Monster/ Redbull

A can of Monster or Red Bull energy drink, offering a boost with a unique blend of caffeine, taurine, and B-group vitamins.

$3.43

Vitamin Water

Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff.

$2.19

Peace Tea

Made with real brewed tea, pure cane sugar, and natural flavors

$1.99

Powerade

A combination of electrolytes and carbohydrates that provide effective hydration and energy.

$1.89

oz Cans

oz cans of soda typically include a range of flavors such as cola, root beer, and ginger ale, served in convenient single-serving cans.

$1.50

oz Soda

A oz soda offers a refreshing and carbonated beverage, available in various flavors to suit your preference.

$2.59

Minute Maid

% Pure squeezed pasteurized orange juice. A delicious orange juice with a taste that’s the next best thing to fresh squeezed.

$2.49